With only seven Rockers left, the line dividing those who are
vulnerable and those who are safe is razor thin. A bad song
selection (or this week, writing a bad song), a less than stellar
stage move, a missed note -- any one of these things could send a
Rocker home.
Before this week's performances begin, Dave wants to clear up
some questions about this week's songs. Why did Suzie suggest that the two
Rockers who get to sing original tunes this week should be picked
out of a hat, then change her mind when she wasn't picked? Why did
MiG remain steadfast in
singing his tune? Why didn't J.D. fight to sing his
original song? And what is it with Marty and modern rock?
Suzie says she thinks her song is really good and that INXS would be impressed.
For MiG it wouldn't really have done anyone any favors (or at least
it wouldn't have done MiG any favors) to switch songs, and he says
he also wants this chance to impress INXS with an original song.
Marty responds that the best way for him to show how he can help
make the dance rock INXS created (which has influenced current
hit-makers such as The Killers and Franz Ferdinand) sound modern is by
singing these types of songs. J.D. is a little less political; he
passed on the chance to sing his own tune because there were epic
rock songs to choose from and "if this is a rock show and (the House Band) is a rock
band, you'd better have a rock song" to sing.
With that, it's time to hear some rock songs, and Suzie kicks
things off with "Start Me Up." The Rolling Stones' last top-five
single also kicks off the legendary British band's current tour, and
Suzie hopes it will stop her reign as "queen of the bottom three."
She delivers the song with great enthusiasm, but there's something a
little too puppyish about her vocal. It feels light and without an
edge. As an added touch, she moves to the Rockers' box, having the
others contribute their vocals to the last chorus, and then dives
into the crowd. Dave calls her performance simply awesome; he's
"shocked" that she ever ended up in the bottom three. Jon calls it
"exceptional," and Tim lauds the fact that she looked and sounded
like she "meant business."
J.D. approaches his performance with a great deal of confidence.
He's sure his performance of Foreigner's top-10 hit "Cold as Ice" will be one of the best of
the night. However, his version lays the guitar riff from Queens of the Stone Age's "Little Sister" over the original's
insistent piano chords. It's a powerful performance, one Dave thinks
makes him already seem a Rock Star. Andrew considers it an exciting
reworking, making a classic rock song modern, while Tim thinks that
J.D. understands what he's doing in this competition and admires his
risk taking.
Deanna is the first of the
two Rockers singing an original song, and she's psyched. She says
that she deserved to be in the bottom three last week, but with this
song she will "kick ass." Her song, "My Truth" (co-written with Ty), is a ballsy rock
song, with a thrashy guitar riff and a chorus that soars like Rise Against. Deanna really pours her
soul into her performance -- this song clearly means something to
her (and to Ty as well, as he sings along with her from the Rockers'
box, with a look Dave compares with a "proud papa"). Dave thinks the
song suits her voice, but Jon worries that it's too much in her
safety zone. Tim asks her about the song's lyrics. They're about a
boyfriend who cheated on her when she was 22, with a singer, an
event that inspired her to become a singer.
Ty is up next. He feels like the golden child this week, getting
two chances to show INXS his talents: as co-writer and arranger of
Deanna's song and with his own performance of "Proud Mary." Taking inspiration from Ike and Tina Turner's hit version
instead of Creedence Clearwater Revival's
original, Ty recruited the three remaining female Rockers to sing
backup. It not only shows his soul; the easy-then-rough arrangement
shows off Ty's emotional range. In his version, the riverboat has
docked in Memphis and he takes the easy, slow opening like Otis Redding. He then drives the second
half like a possessed Wilson Pickett, racing
around the stage, leading the backing vocals and pumping up the
band. Jon speaks for everyone when he exclaims, "That was a show!"
MiG takes the stage next singing his own song, "Do or Die," and
MiG is confident, even if the choice "could blow up in his face." A
moody midtempo tune about his time on the show, the song shows off
MiG's rock side, with dark, grinding verses that turn into a soaring
chorus. Dave likes both his look and the song and is glad to have
the chance to see MiG rock. If MiG makes him cry again, he's "going
to have to reconsider certain things about his personal life." Tim
tells him he should "thank God he fought for the song."
After performing a Britney Spears' song,
Marty was glad to get back to what he's all about: the modern rock
of Live's "I Alone." He needs to make it his own,
and he does, getting, if anything, even more worked up than the
original. Dave calls him "totally relevant to today's rock music,"
even if he occasionally misses a note. Jon would like to hear less
screaming. Tim agrees -- when Marty screams, his pitch is off, but
it really doesn't matter; he pulls it off. Kirk says Marty's really
good, he just has to "work out how it relates to INXS," a remark
that the crowd meets with a chorus of boos.
Jordis closes the night
with Aerosmith's "Dream On." It was a song she was
excited about singing when the tunes were divvied up, but she's been
having problems with it. One note, the high "G" above "C" scream
toward the end of the song, has been giving her trouble. It's
completely out of her range. That note hovers over her entire
performance. She starts with a nice touch, draping a scarf over the
mic stand like Steven Tyler, but she's
tentative, as if every note she sings brings her one note closer to
the one she can't sing. And when she gets to it, it's really not
there for her -- and Dave looks even more pained than she does. It
was not spectacular enough, he tells her, and wants to know why she
didn't try to finesse the note, as she does with other songs. "I'm
trying to stretch myself," she tells him. Tim remains a fan,
although he says it's "nice to see that even you can mess up."
Will Jordis continue her streak of not being in the bottom three?
Will MiG and Deanna's songs connect with listeners? Will J.D.'s
rearrangement succeed with the home audience? For the answers to
these and other questions, tune in to the special one-hour
elimination show Wednesday at 9PM ET/PT on CBS. And point your
browser back here for the recap.